Jambo Davey
Eating fresh fruit salad at an outdoor stall in Nairobi.
JAMBO DAVEY!
Francis was fortunate to have very good friends. At his funeral, Davey met Katy for the first time and they fell in love instantly! Their marriage two years later was memorable. Since then, Davey has attended SOAS (School of Oriental and African Studies) where he studied Politics and East Africa. As he had never been south of Morocco, he wanted to come and see these parts for himself and at the same time, to do some research into the efficacy of NGOs (Non-Governmental Organisation) in Uganda. It suited us both for him to meet me in Nairobi for a week’s holiday.
As soon as our bags were dropped at the hotel after his evening arrival, we were out to walk in the streets of the CBD. Nairobi is the financial capital of Africa, hence its desperate attempt to keep the streets clean and free of hawkers and beggars. I remember only too well the frustrations I had in West Africa to try and obtain money. All transactions had to go through Nairobi first, and whenever there was a delay, that town was blamed. Some Colonial habits die hard: The 20 shilling coin in Kenya is still called a ‘pound’, although it is not worth much. Being a timid female, I had never ventured out at night in Nairobi and it was wonderful to feel so free in Davey´s company. His enthusiasm, intelligence and happy character meant that we could just enjoy the experience. Beggars came out of the shadows and people happily greeted us. This upbeat state of affairs persisted and I am forever grateful to him for opening up a world where I feared to tread. He would talk to anyone and instantly make friends. His lovely sense of humour is exemplified by his astute analysis of a vainglorious ´monument´ which Arap Moi (disgraced previous President) had had erected to himself. The structure spelt out his name MOI, but in no time, Davey had christened it into the French word ´moi´, thus accentuating this man’s arrogance.
Davey´s intelligence and questioning nature was such a tonic for me after a rather bleak time of little intellectual stimulus. Cynthia had kindly offered to host a luncheon and I could bring my friends. Walter, a Dutchman with a Ugandan girlfriend, was a generous taxi driver. He had also once very kindly taken me walking/camping near a crater lake to the west of Nairobi. It was full moon and sitting around the campfire for hours, never stopping in our conversation, had prepared me for Davey and his questioning mind.
We were soon on the overnight train to Mombasa and then spent a night in the little hotel in Kilifi where a ride on the estuary in a dugout catamaran dhow in the very strong moonlight was pure delight. We in the West forget how wonderful the sky can be without light pollution and it has been a joy for me to live by the phases of the moon during this trip.
In Lamu we stayed in a self-contained apartment on top of a beautifully furnished house within the town. It belongs to a well-known Kenyan artist friend of Cynthia, who had recommended it to us. Pure joy to look over the rooftops and to use the little reed-surrounded toilet stuck on the flat roof. Davey excitedly enjoyed seeing the sunrise over the archipelago from his room. His enthusiasm meant not much sleep...
Our return flight to Nairobi from the little airstrip across the water on another island was delayed until we finally boarded a ´plane, just to be dropped off in Malindi (north of Mombasa ) for the night. No problems! Luxury living with swimming pool and Italian food! Malindi is the favourite watering hole of the Italians visiting Kenya and everywhere you go in town is aimed at them.
We were back next day in time to meet up with Stacia, to whom I had introduced Davey at Cynthia’s house. She comes from Chicago and had taught locally for an NGO the year before. After that, she had returned with money collected from friends to work in an orphanage in Kibera, a ´slum´ suburb of Nairobi. It is the largest ´slum´ in Africa and is featured in the film ´The Constant Gardener´. Travelling westwards in the train one overlooks these tightly built corrugated iron structures with narrow lanes and no water or electricity for mile upon mile. Thousands of people live in overcrowded spaces, yet they manage to maintain a living. Davey and I arrived at the appointed place before Stacia met us. We were immediately surrounded by men who were obviously under the influence of drink and drugs. In his inimitable way, Davey was instantly high-five-ing with them, dancing and singing and generally making friends and creating a happy atmosphere. Tensions which an average mzungu like me would have created through fear were instantly dispersed. Stacia and friends arrived and we spent many a happy hour exploring this amazing area. And wherever we went or stopped for a drink or to look at articles for sale, we only met enthusiastic welcomes. Why do we have to fear or condemn people because they live in conditions other than what we in the West accept as desirable? One of my pet-prejudices is against the way the mzungu and other aid-workers in Africa manage to generally find themselves in protected and isolating compounds. No wonder they are regarded as beings from another world. And of course, the image of our lifestyles as depicted in film and TV does not help. On the other hand, most people think of Africa as a place of illness, starvation and poverty, which it emphatically is not.
There is a great tide of disaffection with NGOs taking place. I only reflect my own thoughts based on what one hears. A hilariously cynical book about the whole aid business is ´Cause Celeb´ by Helen Fielding. Do read it! More cynically but truthful, is the book ´Emma’s War` by Deborah Scroggins which depicts the scandal of inter alia, the waste and misappropriation of aid food and medicines in Southern Sudan in the 1970s and 1980s. And most people probably know about the way the Live Aid relief was sold off to Uganda instead of reaching the starving people of Ethiopia. But that is another story of incompetence and corruption with which I will not even begin to deal.
In Ghana, I met researchers who were looking at the way these voluntary organisations double up their activities and do not co-operate. Each NGO of course wants the little old lady in the West to give her sixpence to them only. Cynthia, an experienced historian and anthropologist, has been commissioned to investigate the same phenomenon in the north-west of Kenya. In Uganda, the President has asked for an inquiry into the over 5500 NGOs operating in that country. I was told about one district in Uganda where there were over 200 NGOs covering a relatively small area. During and just after the Rwandan genocide, the country was awash with NGOs all trying to do their own thing and thus getting in the way of each other or doubling up their activities, yet they expected the over-stretched United Nations Peacekeepers to protect them as of right.
Stacia is justifiably sceptical about NGOs, because money, which friends had given via an NGO, never reached the orphanage. Also, the local NGOs were cross with her for not directing funds through them. It meant they lost out on the 25%+ administrative fee. I might sound sceptical, but too many stories are going the rounds. My favourite was told to me by a friend who was in Kenya when he met a young woman who was having a luxury holiday. He asked her how she could afford it, and her reply was that she worked for an NGO and that it was the financial year-end and if they did not spend the money, they would not get the same funds the following year. I know this goes on all the time in business, but we, the public who contribute to these funded organisations, should question them far more. Davey was to study these aspects of NGOs in Uganda.
We travelled overnight by train to Kisumu on the eastern shore of Lake Victoria, but the train was late as usual and we did not have much time to enjoy the ever-moving sea of hyacinth, which is the lake, whilst eating fresh tilapia in one of the many Hotels (Kenyan for ´restaurant´) on the shore. Sadly, hyacinth, killer Nile perch (30 species of endemic Lake Victoria fish consumed by them), pollution, agricultural chemical poisons, diminished water and lack of fish is slowly killing off Africa’s largest Lake. But some of the wonderful 5W ladies of Kisumu managed to meet us and have a brief reunion! For the record, it is here that Barack Obama came to visit his grandmother and the streets/roads were lined with flag-waving well-wishers. And that was before he officially decided to contest the Democratic nomination!
We arrived in Kampala in Uganda in time for Ben, Davey´s friend who teaches at a local school for local wages, to welcome us warmly and give me his bedroom whilst he went to stay with a colleague who lives in another one of the six houses in his compound. The boys went out for the night (and this was followed by many similar outings) and I enjoyed stories of the Kampala nightlife from the distance of a hangover-telling, although I did join them on occasion and could admire the prostitutes, who overran the bars, more closely. They were generally very beautiful and their dress-sense and makeup could be the envy of any London West End lady. Davey was happy to show them his wedding ring and they respected his loyalty and just had a good time with the boys.
One day Ben generously killed one of his 4 chickens for supper and I enjoyed showing the boys how to disembowel it. My father’s sister had had one of the most extensive chicken farms in South Africa in the 1950/60s when well-fed and free-range chickens were a total luxury. She supplied the very large hotels in Durban and the whole of South African Railways with eggs. Every Christmas she would give over 50 chickens to friends as presents and my job was to help get them ready. It sounds macabre, but we are just too far removed from reality in the West whereas here in Africa, it is a pleasure for me to get back to what living is about. If we want to eat meat, the least we can do is to know where it comes from and how it gets there. I might sound as though I have been here too long, but it is just that I think the people of Africa still have a sense of how to live with nature which we so often deny ourselves. Discuss!
I soon left to stay with Liz, Ben’s mother, in Kabale in the south-west of Uganda and Davey departed for an NGO with which Liz had arranged for him to get some hands-on experience.
He subsequently made all kinds of contacts and I am sure is full of ideas and plans for the future and an exciting MA dissertation. I eventually disappeared into Rwanda and we could only say goodbye via email.
It had never been my intention to visit Uganda during this trip southwards, but Davey had inspired me to go back up north and there was no reason why not to do so. I had been in the south of Uganda in 2002 when I took part in a first-ever sponsored cycle ride from Lake Mburo to Rwanda for the Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund. Collecting money and asking friends for contributions was horrible! But the trip was great and I did manage to see the gorillas. Since then, there have been similar cycle trips every year. What stands out in my memory is the beautiful scenery and deep lakes amongst high mountains with numerous islands. Quite magical!
Liz lives in Kabale where she works for VSO and is an incredibly experienced and competent worker. She is involved in setting up a grass-roots anti-corruption NGO. It is only through teaching via community-based organisations, that the understanding of ´corruption´ can be taught. When she and fellow NGO workers are together, my mind reels with the way they talk! It is a shorthand language with acronyms being used all the time. She had hoped that I could assist a local NGO which works with disabled people, but once I visited and realised that the Chinese Manager, who has only been here for two months, needed to get a grip on the situation himself, I threw in some ideas and left them to it. Too many cooks…
One of the volunteer people with whom Liz works, is a local Tourist Guide. Warren was enthusiastic to learn all he could from me about Guiding. I had been sceptical about the quality of guiding instruction the local college was giving when I visited them and Warren subsequently told me that he lectured there as well as at the local university. Anyway, the outcome was that he asked me to give a lecture to students from both organisations. It was hard work! African education is still in the area of students just sitting quietly at their desks and never making a sound. What they take in is a debatable point. Later in Rwanda, I spoke to a VSO Educational Consultant and he was in despair about the system! Why teach children complicated fractions when they will never need them and cannot understand anyway? And I remember in Kenya sitting in on a class in an orphanage I was visiting in which the teacher was telling students about the sun and planets. I was very tempted to tell him that Pluto had been declassified and was no longer a planet, but when the books from which teachers are teaching are old and out of date, one cannot interfere. Being in huts or outdoors under a tree does not lead to checking things on the internet! Anyway, to return to my lecture: I realised that the students did not take in a thing I was saying when I tried to ask questions. My role-playing baffled them and there was total silence. Therefore, I took them all outside to emphasis that Tourist Guiding is a Practical Profession. This really threw them into a state of confusion! Whether my presence had any lasting effect, is debatable, but Warren wrote copious notes and was inspired!
I manage to put the cat amongst the pigeons at times when I say that compulsory education should be stopped. Here in Africa, where it is regarded as such a privilege to aim for and when people go hungry to pay for school fees, my attitude is incomprehensible. In the West, however, we have had over 100 years of compulsory education and it has not necessarily produced an educated population. Where education is free and compulsory, there are often students who just do not want to learn and as a result, disrupt the class for those who do. In England, teachers are often just trying to maintain discipline. Students who have to stay at school until they are 16 often leave without being literate. Is this a scandal? Not necessarily. As long as facilities are available for them if they ever want to learn, let them go and become entrepreneurs or labourers. They will manage. I have recently read H G Wells´s ´The Time Machine´. Written in the 1890s, it is the first real science fiction book. But he was a realist. He could foresee that mankind was not necessarily going to go on being well-educated and better through the application of science and education. Mankind’s striving for happiness will eventually lead to diminishing of intellect. Oh dear, I am treading on toes!
The above was sent to Davey to have a look at, and
Davey responded with the following…
I like your digs at attitudes to slums/poverty, the comments on non-governmental disorganisations, and the brief critique of the attempts to institute universal education. Perhaps the most damning criticisms I heard to do with the latter were practical and grave: There are simply not enough schools and teachers to cope with such a programme.This has resulted in classes of up to 200 kids being taught by some barely-qualified (but doubtless well-meaning) buffoon.
It also means that kids are not able to help their parents out in whatever work they are doing, or even simply take care of household responsibilities while the parents are working elsewhere.Western attitudes to this latter aspect are often based on some spurious notion of what children can and can't do and what they ought to be doing. e.g. the Dutch woman who taught at the Masaka disabled school related to me in shocked terms about a family she met in which the 5 yr old daughter was expected to look after a 3 yr old sister during the day. I don't know how common such circumstances are, but surely we have to weigh such arguably undesirable situations with others in which young children learn domestic responsibilities and useful skills, not to mention building themselves up physically by carrying water butts etc.
This latter point is especially interesting to me in view of the chronic child obesity problems we have in the more civilised parts of the world.Much of the universal education programme has been motivated by a desire on the part of the NRM to appear 'progressive' in the eyes of the donor community - regardless of the efficacy of such programmes and their potentially disastrous effects on Ugandan family life.
Meanwhile, an intellectual (Omar) told me, the quality of education at a higher level has been deteriorating due to 'commercialisation' of the main universities and the co-option of graduates into NGO jobs. The commercialisation purports to re-structure university courses according to the job market, which means that the degrees are becoming almost exclusively directed towards business and the NGO sector.
This may sound good and practical, but the result is that there is very little room for encouraging critical thinking and promoting socio-political, and even aesthetic, awareness.
The intellectual, Omar, teaches at Makerere International - the second biggest university in Uganda. Almost all of his students, he said, were intent on getting a cosy job with a foreign firm/NGO, and were fixated on consumer goods.
Interestingly, my favorite teacher at SOAS also made similar complaints: "Where have all the student radicals gone?" he asked.
While I have been struggling to find an answer to this question in the English context, Omar provided one for his country. The NGOs and businesses are not only not interested in 'politics', they actively discourage discussion of political affairs. Someone who appears too 'political' will simply not get a job, or will not get promoted (or even get sacked) if they start taking an interest in trade unions (or whatever) while already employed. Such an environment makes it very difficult for an intellectual and even arts-based scene to flourish, especially as the middle-class audience that typically forms the core of such scenes are precisely those who are embracing consumerism and the 'de-politicised' world of foreign employment with such enthusiasm.
The scare quotes around 'political' and 'de-politicised' are there because, of course, in such affairs, everything is 'political'.
The presence of so many foreigners who are effectively re-structuring Uganda's economy, society and culture is surely a matter for political debate. You mention people complaining more about the efficacy of the NGO programmes etc. In my experience, yes and no. People in Uganda seemed generally uncritical of the British presence, past and present. They had a certain antipathy towards the French and Yanks who they deemed arrogant (prejudice doubtless passed on from the colonisers). They might not have had an independence struggle on the scale of the Mau Mau (indeed nothing really comparable), but that doesn't mean they were not exploited and continue to be.
The real antipathy seems reserved for the MuHindi community - and understandably so, in a way. Because the mzungu pay better wages and pay them on time, because they treat their workers well, and because they even intermarry, they are seen as generally beneficent - which is great for people like me, who are treated so hospitably as a result! However, I noticed a complete lack of cynicism (amongst almost everyone) re. Blair's and Clinton's attitudes to Africa. , Omar the intellectual said that during both Bushes' administrations, and during the Conservative years (in UK), Africans tended to be left alone to forge their own futures. He went further, saying that during colonial times, people like him (who questioned the proliferation of foreigners in his country) had a target: basically a pith helmet. "Now" he said with a smile, "I don't know where to shoot. They're everywhere and doing so many different things, you don't know who the good guys and the bad guys are..."
I (pretentiously) used terms like 'network power' and 'diffuse strategies' to conceptualise what was happening now, and he agreed. There were good, straightforward projects (he said), such as those of the military that we all talked about at Cynthia's - where, e.g., they come into a village, dig some wells using Western technology, and then leave. Others, however, are more keen to re-structure society on deeper levels, attempting to create new types of people (basically modern, liberal citizens) rather than simply helping what already exists, to work. Ultimately there are no black and white answers to these vexed and complex questions. For one thing (despite Omar's distaste for liberal internationalists like Blair/Clinton) it is not really useful to imagine an Africa without foreigners meddling in it - there will always be muzungu there making a buck, at least.
The real question is what kind of 'interventions' are more beneficial for the objects of intervention.That is a very moral question concerning what kind of society and future does one see as desirable for Ugandans. But that does not mean it should not be asked.
By hobbling the radicals thru education reform and an effective silencing of political debate, 'Development' (as a general project) becomes what one British critic has termed 'The Anti-Politics Machine'. There is no debate because there is no question that development along Western lines is undesirable. The debates are how to enable Development, how to encourage some narrowly conceived notion of 'citizenship', how to eradicate child labour, or whatever - not whether these outcomes are desirable or even possible in the first place. This is analogous (for me) with the new direction of British politics: Blair's Third Way, with his emphasis on globalisation as "irreversible and irresistible", basically starts from the premise that the left/right debate is over - that there really can be no ideological debate now, simply a kind of tussle over which elected bureaucrat gets to oversee the implementation of Thatcher's legacy. Thus debates on 'Britishness' emerge, no longer centering on what kind of economy we should have, but on what our 'values' are, whether those immigrants next door are 'like us' or not, etc.While previously the domain of fringe racists, such arguments are now being taken seriously in No.10 Downing Street - doubtless partly because of our higher exposure to Islamic terrorism (Thanks Tony!).In the Ugandan society, such a situation is manifest in the tendency to attack the easy target of the MuHindi businessman, while ignoring the presence of the impoverished and illiterate Ugandan Asians, and more importantly, while not addressing the environment which enables the kind of exploitation that is deplored. Omar the intellectual emphasised the connections between this ignorance, the education reforms, and the presence of rich mzungu employers and experts all over Uganda. Sorry for this slightly vague ramble, but I thought you might like to hear the results of my 'investigation'. In the end, I didn't exhaustively probe the new Heart of Darkness or whatever, but the taster was delightful and fascinating.It has really only whetted my appetite, and as I said in my last mail, I am very much looking for any excuse to get back out there and really get stuck in.
Davey’s remarks were sent to a retired expat Historian who has spent his life in East Africa and now lives in Nairobi. I include it just to make one aware of all the thinking that is going on around the world. Lateral thinking is finally being considered!
Hi Hilda,
Interesting! A can of worms!
In my view, the current 'development apparatus' which is variously being offered or imposed upon or claimed by Africa is based on a narrow definition of technology. It is a technology/science which draws all things toward urban conglomerates, toward traffic jams, toward crowded school rooms, toward people who need antiretrovirals full time to stay alive, etc. etc.
In a recent article in the New York Review of Books, Freeman Dyson suggests that this distorted matrix of modern civilization is but a short phase in the evolutionary process. In his optimistic view, in future science/technology will become more relevant to the needs of the masses of people living in rural areas and will draw on and apply to a much broader range of resources. I suspect he is too optimistic. But I do agree on the need (and hopefully, a trend) for a focus of science and technology on the welfare of both urban and non-urban folks. Clearly the present pattern is not workable for the long run.
A book by Paul Dawken entitled 'Blessed Unrest' tries to quantify in the broadest terms those millions of people groups around the world who resist the dictates of modernity or, alternatively, identify new and more humane applications of technology. Dawken compares these armies in favor of alternative options with the human immune system. One obtains some sense of the intended shape of the human being by examining the workings of its immune systems. Similarly, one obtains a sense of what the future of the world might look like by examining the cumulative work/vision/experimentation by the 'alternatives'. Interesting.
Like the wag said: 'Don't change your mind; it is reality that is wrong!'
Best wishes. Many greetings. Harold Miller
Although I had read the book, I did not choose the following quotation. It was sent in by Stacia who had so happily taken us around Kibera and who was having big problems with the local NGOs who did not like her ‘hands-on’ method of helping in an orphanage.
Quote from "The Zanzibar Chest" by Aidan Hartley:
"... Only a handful of volunteers were there to help at the start. Every humanitarian disaster is a golden fund raising opportunity for the charities. One Christian outfit worked all day praying rather than distributing food, shelter or IV fluids.... Africa may be the world's poorest place but it is rich in men of God. It's unfortunate that the Africans no longer boil them up in pots and serve them for dinner."